1237 Pocantico LN, Naples
(239) 216-2016
Real Estate Company

A red-shouldered hawk on the sixth fairway — sanctuary residents are part of daily life here. Photo: Peter W. Thayer / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 3.0
NAPLES, FLORIDA · IMMOKALEE ROAD · COCOHATCHEE RIVER
Two hundred twenty-four estate homes on 450 acres of river, oak hammock and preserve — and a country club that is not an add-on but part of the deed. This guide covers what buyers actually ask us: how the mandatory membership really works, what the fees add up to, the golf, the rental rules, and why this small community on the Cocohatchee stays one of Naples' most quietly coveted addresses.
LAST UPDATED: NOVEMBER 2026 · FEE DETAILS CHECKED OCTOBER 2026 AGAINST CURRENT MLS LISTINGS AND THE CLUB'S RECORDED COVENANTS; MARKET DATA: MATRIX MLS, NOVEMBER 2026
VIEW ALL COLLIERS RESERVE HOMES FOR SALE ↓
|
COLLIERS RESERVE AT A GLANCE
|
| ALL-IN RECURRING, AS LISTINGS PRINT IT $29,218/yr — HOA plus the mandatory social-tier club dues, before any golf |
MANDATORY CLUB DUES ≈$15,200–$16,200/yr — plus a $1,500/yr food & beverage minimum |
| GOLF DUES, IF YOU JOIN ≈$24,000–$26,500/yr — published range; the club publishes no price list |
TRANSFER AT PURCHASE $19,500–$47,500 — depending on the sale, per recent listings |
Colliers Reserve in the Naples HOA fee comparison →
Fees checked October 2026 against current MLS listings and the club's recorded covenants. Colliers Reserve has no separate fee-breakdown page; its card in the Naples HOA fee comparison is the register's entry for this community.
Colliers Reserve trades in small numbers — 224 homes, and only a handful change hands in a typical year — so read any single median with care. The last 12 months were busier than most: 16 sales, every one a single-family estate home, at a median of $2,637,500 — a touch below the prior year's $2,800,000 median on 12 sales, a move that says more about which estates sold than about values. Sales closed at a median of 90.62% of asking in a median of 96 days, at $596.69 per square foot, and the year's sales ran from $1,550,000 to $3,700,000. What holds steady is the shape of the market: estate homes, long ownership, and buyers who come for the club and the sanctuary as much as the house.
| $2,637,500 MEDIAN SALE PRICE, LAST 12 MONTHS |
16 HOMES SOLD, LAST 12 MONTHS |
| 90.62% SALE PRICE AS % OF ASKING |
4.5 mo MONTHS OF SUPPLY |
The most recent 120 days brought 5 sales at a higher $3,200,000 median and 94.58% of asking — but at a median of 223 days on market: those were long-listed estates finally meeting their buyers, not a sudden rush. Supply calculates to 4.5 months against the trailing year's pace — balanced on paper, though in a community this small a single listing or closing moves every figure on this page.
Market data: Matrix MLS (Southwest Florida MLS) · November 2026. Months of supply is calculated from Matrix active and sold counts. Refreshed quarterly — see our full Naples market report.
|
LOOKING AT A SPECIFIC COLLIERS RESERVE HOME? Call or text (239) 216-2016 I will walk you through the numbers for any specific home — the mandatory membership math, the transfer fee on that sale, what the sanctuary setting gives you, and what is coming to market. |
Colliers Reserve does not hide its costs, but it does layer them: an HOA fee, a club membership written into the covenants, and — only if you choose it — golf on top. Budgeted properly, there are no surprises; budgeted as "just the HOA," there is one big one. Here is the full stack:
| Master HOA — $8,900/yr (2026 listings) The community association fee every owner pays. Earlier 2026 listings printed $8,520 — the current figure in the newest listings is $8,900. |
| Club membership (mandatory) — $80,000 one-time + dues Every buyer joins Collier's Reserve Country Club at the Sports Social level — the requirement sits in the community's recorded covenants, not in a sales pitch. Current listings put the annual mandatory club fee at roughly $15,200–$16,200, plus a $1,500/yr food-and-beverage minimum. Add the HOA and the all-in recurring total in current listings is $29,218/yr. |
| Golf membership (optional) — $225,000 one-time Golf is a separate, genuinely optional decision — capped at 300 memberships across a 224-home community. Published dues run roughly $24,000–$26,500/yr depending on the source; the club publishes no price list, so confirm the current schedule before you budget. |
| CDD / district assessments — None found No community development district charge appears in Colliers Reserve listings. |
A transfer fee applies at purchase, and recent listings put it anywhere from $19,500 to $47,500 depending on the sale — one more reason the membership math for a specific home belongs in the offer conversation, not after it.
See Colliers Reserve in the Naples HOA fee comparison →
Fees checked October 2026 against current MLS listings and the club's recorded covenants. Colliers Reserve has no separate fee-breakdown page; its card in the Naples HOA fee comparison is the register's entry for this community.
There are no condos, villas or coach homes in Colliers Reserve — every one of the 224 residences is a custom-built single-family estate home, and that single-format discipline is a large part of why the community feels the way it does. The variety is in the land:
Riverfront estates — homes on the Cocohatchee River, some with private docks, where the waterway leads out toward Wiggins Pass and the Gulf. Best for: boaters and kayakers who want the river as their back yard.
Golf-course estates — homes wrapped around the Arthur Hills layout, with fairway views set into oak hammock and preserve rather than the other way around. Best for: golf members who want the course at the garden gate.
Preserve estates — interior homes fronting the protected conservation land — roughly 130 of the 450 acres are permanently preserved — for the deepest quiet in the community. Best for: full-time residents who prize privacy over panorama.
Colliers Reserve holds a distinction no other golf community on earth can copy: in 1994 it became the first golfing community in the world designated a Certified Audubon International Signature Sanctuary — a title it still carries, with Gold Certification added in 2017. The Arthur Hills course (18 holes, par 72, opened 1993) was routed through the hammocks and wetlands rather than over them, which is why a round here feels less like landscaping and more like a walk in a nature preserve that happens to have greens.
Off the course, the club's Sports Center covers tennis, pickleball and a state-of-the-art fitness center; the Clubhouse handles fine dining, and the Boathouse on the river handles the casual end — and is where you launch a kayak for the paddle down the Cocohatchee to the Gulf of Mexico. It is a full country-club life, deliberately kept at 224-home scale.
Public-school zoning is uniform across Colliers Reserve: Naples Park Elementary, North Naples Middle School and Aubrey Rogers High School. School zoning changed in 2023 when Aubrey Rogers High opened — some older listings still show Gulf Coast.
School assignments are per Collier County Public Schools zoning as of October 2026 — confirm for your specific address before you buy.
| NCH North Naples Hospital | about 10 minutes |
| Delnor-Wiggins Pass State Park (Vanderbilt Beach) | about 10 minutes |
| Mercato (dining, Whole Foods) | about 10 minutes |
| Waterside Shops | about 15 minutes |
| Fifth Avenue South | about 25 minutes |
| Naples Airport | about 25 minutes |
| RSW (Fort Myers) | about 40 minutes |
Drive times are approximate and grow in season (January–April). The sanctuary, the river and the club need no drive at all — they are the neighborhood itself.
How much are the HOA fees in Colliers Reserve?
The master HOA is $8,900 a year in current listings — but that is not the whole bill. Every owner also carries the mandatory club membership (below), and current listings total $29,218 a year in recurring fees for a resident on the social tier.
Do I have to join the club to live in Colliers Reserve?
Yes. Club membership at the Sports Social level is required of every buyer — it is written into the community's recorded covenants. The one-time initiation is $80,000, with annual dues of roughly $15,200–$16,200 in current listings plus a $1,500 yearly food-and-beverage minimum. Golf membership is the optional layer on top.
How much is the golf membership?
Initiation is $225,000, with published annual dues of roughly $24,000–$26,500 depending on the source. Golf memberships are capped at 300 — in a community of 224 homes — and golf is never required: the mandatory tier is social.
Can I rent out a Colliers Reserve home?
Yes, within the association's rules: a home may be leased one time per year, for a minimum of four months. The lease and a registration form go to the association at least 15 days before your tenant arrives, and your tenant receives use of the club at your membership level for the term of the lease.
Is there a CDD or capital fee?
No CDD charge appears in Colliers Reserve listings, and there is no community-wide capital contribution. A transfer fee does apply at purchase — recent listings range from $19,500 to $47,500 — alongside the $80,000 social initiation.
Is Colliers Reserve gated?
Yes — it is a private community with monitored access around the clock, and at 224 homes on 450 acres it stays small on purpose.
|
MICHAEL'S TAKE Colliers Reserve is the community I recommend when a buyer wants a real country club without the mega-community scale — 224 homes on 450 acres of river and hammock, the world's first Audubon Signature Sanctuary, and a kayak launch at the Boathouse that puts you on the Cocohatchee heading for the Gulf before breakfast. Know what you are buying, though: the club is not optional equipment here — the social membership, its $80,000 initiation and its dues are part of the purchase, written into the covenants, and golf is a second decision at $225,000 on top. Buy the membership math first, then the house. |
KEEP EXPLORING
Explore Nearby Communities
| Pelican Marsh → Golf community just south, where the club stays optional |
Vanderbilt Beach → Gulf-front towers about ten minutes west |
Pelican Bay → Private beach and tram, just southwest |
| Park Shore → Beach park and Venetian Bay dining, south on the Gulf |
The Vineyards → Two-course country club east on the Immokalee corridor |
Grey Oaks → Naples' premier golf club community |
|
THINKING ABOUT COLLIERS RESERVE? Call or text (239) 216-2016 Buying or selling, start with a conversation: the membership math, the transfer fee, and what 224-home scarcity does to value — on either side of the table. No obligation MICHAEL O'REILLY · REALTOR® AND BROKER ASSOCIATE, DOWNING-FRYE REALTY, INC. · OS FLORIDA GROUP |
The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than this company are marked with the BR Program Icon or the BR House Icon and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available through the BR Program. The information provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose.
Get instant property value now!